Using vaccine challenge model of T. gondii infection, we found that treatments with two commonly used for NK cell depletion antibodies resulted in different survival outcomes during secondary infection. Anti-ASGM1 resulted in 100% death and greater parasite burden at the site of infection than anti-NK1.1. Anti-NK1.1 treatment resulted in increased parasite burdens, but animals did not die. Further we found that anti-ASGM1 treatment depleted T cells. CD8+ T cells were more susceptible that CD4+ T cells to the treatment. ASGM1 was expressed on a higher percentage of CD8+ T cells than CD4+ T cells and CD8+ T cells. In T. gondii-immunized animals ASGM1 was enriched on effector memory (Tem) and central memory (Tcm) CD8+ T cells. However, Tem were more susceptible to the treatment. After secondary infection, Tem, Tcm, effector (Tef) and naive (Tn) CD8+ T cells were positive for ASGM1. Anti-ASGM1 treatment during reinfection resulted in greater depletion of activated IFN{gamma}+, Granzyme B+, Tem and Tef than Tcm and Tn CD8+ T cells. Anti-ASGM1 also depleted IFN{gamma}+ CD4+ T cells. Recombinant IFN{gamma} supplementation prolonged survival of anti-ASGM1 treated mice, demonstrating that this antibody eliminated IFN{gamma}-producing T and NK cells important for control of the parasite. These results highlight that anti-ASGM1 antibody is not an optimal choice for targeting only NK cells and more precise approaches should be used. This study uncovers ASGM1 as a marker of activated effector T cells and the potential importance of changes in sialylation in lipid rafts for T cell activation during T. gondii infection.